Journal Information
Vol. 24. Num. 6.
Pages 321-362 (November - December 2018)
Share
Share
Download PDF
More article options
Visits
838
Vol. 24. Num. 6.
Pages 321-362 (November - December 2018)
Research letter
DOI: 10.1016/j.pulmoe.2018.09.005
Open Access
Functionality of patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease at 3 months follow-up after elastic resistance training: a randomized clinical trial
Visits
838
Isis Grigoletto Silvaa,
Corresponding author
isis_grigoletto@hotmail.com

Corresponding author. São Paulo State University (UNESP), Faculty of Science and Technology, Presidente Prudente, Brazil, Department of Physical Therapy, Address: 305, Roberto Simonsen St. Presidente Prudente, SP, Brazil. Zipcode: 19060-900. Tel.: +55 18 32295821
, Bruna Spolador de Alencar Silvab, Ana Paula Coelho Figueira Freirea, Ana Paula Soares dos Santosa, Fabiano Francisco de Limaa, Dionei Ramosa, Ercy Mara Cipulo Ramosa
a Department of Physical Therapy, São Paulo State University (UNESP), Faculty of Science and Technology, Presidente Prudente, São Paulo, Brazil
b Department of Physical Education, São Paulo State University (UNESP), Institute of Biosciences, Rio Claro, São Paulo, Brazil
This item has received
838
Visits

Under a Creative Commons license
Article information
Full Text
Bibliography
Download PDF
Statistics
Tables (2)
Table 1. Anthropometric and spirometric characteristics of the groups. Data expressed as mean and ± standard error.
Table 2. Variables of functional capacity, body composition and questionnaires of quality of life, sleep disturbances and physical activity level expressed as mean ± standard error.
Show moreShow less
Full Text
INTRODUCTION

Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) present musculoskeletal disorders, which result in exercise intolerance, a decline in quality of life (QoL)1 and poor sleep quality2. It is proven that the use of elastic tools in resistance training for patients with COPD is beneficial in improving the functional capacity, QoL and muscle strength3,4. However, it is unknown if the benefits achieved with elastic resistance training using elastic bands and tubes, are maintained after the program, in COPD. Considering the advantages (low cost and portability) of these elastic tools, as well as the benefits for these patients3, it is necessary to evaluate the functionality, health status, and body composition at the end of the training program.

The objective of this study was to analyze functional capacity, body composition, QoL and Physical Activity (PA) level at 3 months follow-up after 12 weeks of elastic resistance training in patients with COPD.

METHODSSample

The sample size was defined using the study of Ramos et al. (2014)3. In order to evaluate the study parameters a six-minute walk test (6MWT) was carried out by 54 patients divided into three groups. The duration of the study lasted 24 weeks (12 weeks of training and 12 weeks of follow-up). Participants signed the consent form. All the procedures performed were approved by the Research Ethics Committee (approval number of the Ethics Committee: 1.677.874).

Study design

A total of 81 patients diagnosed with COPD were recruited. Of these, 48 patients were randomized into three groups: Elastic Band Training Group (EBG), Elastic Tube Training Group (ETG) and Training Group with Conventional Weight Machines (CG). The 3 months follow-up sample was composed of 33 patients, and the study was registered in the Brazilian Clinical Trials Registry (REBEC: RBR-6V9SJJ).

An assessment was individually performed before the beginning of the training, after completing the program training (12 weeks) and after 3 months of follow-up (24 weeks), these evaluations were: spirometry (conducted to confirm the diagnosis of COPD)1, body composition (assessed using bioimpedance analysis - Octopolar InBody 720, Biospace, Seoul, Korea), functional capacity (6MWT)1, QoL (analyzed by COPD Assessment Test- CAT and sleep disorders assessed by the Mini-Sleep Questionnaire - MSQ). To evaluate PA levels the Baecke Questionnaire (BQ) was used.

Training protocol

The training program was performed for 12 weeks, three times per week, 60minutes per session. Materials used included elastic bands (EBG) and elastic tubes (ETG) using chairs specially designed with fixed hooks for these groups, as well as conventional equipment (CG). The exercises used during intervention were: knee extension, knee flexion, shoulder flexion, abduction of shoulder and elbow flexion.

Training protocol consisted of a Maximum Number of Repetitions (MNR) in each set. Therefore, the patient was submitted to a load that had only the MNR imposed by the training dynamics; this consisted of twelve weeks with 2x15 (first week) up to 3x15 (last week) repetitions. The increase in the training load was introduced during the execution of the movement, for EBG and ETG were carried out by adding tubes or bands in the fixed-hooks. The thickness of the elastic tubes indicated different resistances; the greater the thickness the greater the resistance. For CG free weights and pulleys were used.

Statistical analysis

One-way ANOVA was performed to identify the difference between groups at baseline. A 3x3 repeated measures analysis of variance (RMANOVA) with Bonferroni adjustment for multiple comparisons was used to compare group (EBG, ETG and CG) and responses of time (baseline, post training and follow-up). For the comparison between groups (delta values: post training minus baseline and follow-up minus post training) Student T test or Mann Witney was used according to data distribution. Statistical significance was set at p<0.05. The effect size (eta-squared; η2) was calculated across time.

RESULTS

Anthropometric and spirometric characteristics of the groups are presented in Table 1.

Table 1.

Anthropometric and spirometric characteristics of the groups. Data expressed as mean and ± standard error.

  EBG [n=12 (6 men)]  ETG [n=11 (7 men)]  CG [n=10 (7 men)] 
Anthropometric variables
Age  66.7±2.40  72.82±1.94  66.40±3.94  0.1492 
Weight (Kg)  74.64±3.30  59.18±3.34a  74.70±3.21  0.0055 
Height (m)  1.60±0.02  1.61±0.04  1.65±0.02  0.3537 
BMI (Kg/m229.30±1.29  22.97±1.12b  27.36±1.05  0.0051 
Pulmonary Function
FEV1 (L)  1.44±0.16  1.15±0.12  1.58±0.16  0.1650 
FEV1% pred  54.8±5.38  43.1±4.25  54.43±5.12  0.1880 
FVC (L)  2.61±0.23  2.36±0.27  2.60±0.20  0.8610 
FEV1/FVC (%)  55.15±3.76  50.56±3.41  60.44±3.93  0.1726 

EBG: Elastic band group; ETG: Elastic tube group; CG: Training group with conventional weight machines; Kg: Kilogram; m: meters; Kg/m2: kilogram per square meter; L: Liters; BMI: Body Mass Index; FEV1: Forced expiratory volume in the first second; FEV1% predicted: Forced expiratory volume in the first second percentage predicted; FVC: Forced vital capacity; FEV1/FCV: Ratio between forced expiratory volume in the first second and forced vital capacity; %: percentage.

a

: Statistically significant difference compared to EBG and CG in weight.

b

: Statistically significant difference compared to EBG and CG in BMI.

A total of 33 patients with COPD completed the study, divided into: EBG (degree = GOLD I: 2 patients (17%), GOLD II: 4 (33%), GOLD III: 5 (42%), GOLD IV: 1 (8%); ETG (degree = GOLD I: 0 patients (0%), GOLD II: 3 (27%), GOLD III: 7 (64%), GOLD IV: 1 (9%) and CG (degree = GOLD I: 0 patients (0%), GOLD II: 6 (60%), GOLD III: 3 (30%), GOLD IV: 1 (10%).The results of functional capacity, questionnaires (CAT, MSQ, and PA) and body composition are presented in

Within the three groups, only CAT questionnaire presented a significant decrease over the three assessments (p<0.05) however, the post- hoc was not significant. Although not a significant one, only among patients from the ETG group was there a decline in their functional capacity after the program. Comparing follow-up with post-program, all three groups reduced their functional capacity but with a similar non-significant amount for EBG and CG, while reaching the Minimum Clinically Important Difference (MCID) on the ETG. The other variables remained stable.

There was a MCID in CAT in EBG and ETG when comparing baseline and after 12 weeks of training (EBG = -2.76 points; ETG= -3.50 points). Table 2

Table 2.

Variables of functional capacity, body composition and questionnaires of quality of life, sleep disturbances and physical activity level expressed as mean ± standard error.

    Baseline  12 weeks  Δ post-pre  Follow-up  Δ follow-up-post  Effect  Effect size 
Functional capacity                     
  EBG  511.25±26.36  527.58±27.01  17.18±13.25  517.33±24.43  -10.25±13.99  Group  0.40  0.96  0.71 
6MWT (m)  ETG  465.78±18.98  457.27±15.13  -8.63±6.96  431.67±19.77  -29.20±12.25  Group x time  0.57  0.74  0.06 
  CG  497.33±32.91  509.45±25.50  3.94±8.65  499.20±36.00  -10.25±18.53  Time  0.23  1.53  0.06 
Body Composition                     
  EBG  20.48±0.79  20.33±0.79  -0.17±0.15  20.69±0.83  0.37±0.15  Group  0.20  1.70  0.10 
IWM (Kg)  ETG  18.40±1.09  18.77±1.05  0.31±0.22  18.24±1.00  1.17±1.72  Group x time  0.29  1.29  0.08 
  CG  20.01±2.20  22.08±1.39  2.33±2.15  21.98±1.35  -0.10±0.22  Time  0.24  1.46  0.05 
                     
  EBG  8.86±0.35  8.79±0.34  -0.07±0.06  8.96±0.36  0.17±0.07  Group  0.20  1.68  0.10 
PM (Kg)  ETG  7.95±0.47  8.12±0.45  0.15±0.095  7.87±0.43  0.49±0.74  Group x time  0.31  1.23  0.08 
  CG  8.66±0.95  9.55±0.60  1.01±0.93  9.46±0.60  -0.09±0.09  Time  0.25  1.41  0.05 
                     
  EBG  45.30±1.74  44.72±1.69  -0.64±0.48  45.81±1.83  1.09±0.39  Group  0.25  1.44  0.09 
FFM (Kg)  ETG  41.20±2.46  42.03±2.35  0.74±0.51  40.85±2.20  2.64±3.85  Group x time  0.27  1.37  0.09 
  CG  44.30±4.63  48.68±2.94  4.96±4.55  48.42±2.88  -0.26±0.46  Time  0.25  1.38  0.47 
Quality of life                     
  EBG  14.18±2.38  11.42±2.14  -0.45±1.80  13.08±2.30  1.67±1.06  Group  0.61  0.51  0.04 
CAT (score)  ETG  19.40±2.76  15.90±3.30  -2.13±4.70  16±2.43  0.09±3.21  Group x time  0.98  0.43  0.07 
  CG  15.30±2.86  14.20±3.00  -0.78±2.46  12±2.80  -2.20±1.44  Time  0.02*  0.50  0.15 
Sleep disturbances                     
  EBG  33.20±3.28  29.17±2,17  2.45±3.51  30.25±2.07  1.08±1.20  Group  0.72  0.34  0.02 
MSQ (score)  ETG  29.67±3.88  29.90±2.77  1.00±1.84  27.36±2.89  0.18±3.28  Group x time  0.32  1.20  0.08 
  CG  27.5±2.37  28.4±2.62  -0.44±1.56  30.4±2.44  2.00±1.83  Time  0.93  0.03  0.001 
Physical Activity                     
  EBG  4.99±0.36  4.74±0.36  0.30±0.58  5.05±0.29  0.18±0.46  Group  0.63  0.47  0.03 
BQ (score)  ETG  4.49±0.73  4.32±0.65  -0.20±0.22  4.28±0.52  0.35±0.30  Group x time  0.98  0.12  0.01 
  CG  5.03±0.58  4.93±.0.53  -0.24±0.40  5.28±0.52  0.35±0.29  Time  0.50  0.70  0.02 

EBG: Elastic band group; ETG: Elastic tube group; CG: Training group with conventional weight machine; 6MWT: Six-minute walk test; IWM: Intracellular water mass; PM: Protein mass; FFM: Fat free mass; CAT: COPD Assessment Test; MSQ: Mini-Sleep Questionnaire; BQ: Baecke Questionnaire; m: meters; Kg: Kilogram; Δ post-pre: difference between baseline and 12 weeks evaluations of each group expressed as mean and standard error; Δ follow-up-post: difference between 3 months of follow-up and 12 weeks evaluations of each group expressed as mean and standard error; Effect: Comparisons of group (EBG, ETG and CG) and responses of time (Baseline, 12 weeks and 3 months of follow-up);

*: statistical significance p<0.05.

DISCUSSION

Patients with COPD maintained their body composition and PA levels at 3 months follow-up using elastic components. However, although not significant, there was a decrease in functional capacity. The QoL was also maintained, and MCID was observed in EBG and ETG after 12 weeks of intervention.

It is known that the elderly associated to chronic diseases have a predisposition to functional disability5,6. The results of the present study showed a decrease in functional capacity at 3 months follow-up when using elastic components, suggesting the importance of the continuity of program performed to maintain functional capacity6. This may be explained by age and pulmonary function, that even if these values were not statistically different between groups, the ETG presented higher age and lower pulmonary function values.

Pulmonary Rehabilitation Program (PRP) promotes QoL improvements in patients with COPD7 while sleep disturbances are detrimental to QoL and can lead to mental and physical illness, increasing health expenditure and mortality8. PA is an important protective factor for sleep disorders in the elderly9. Maintenance of body composition in patients with COPD is of extreme importance to reduce mortality10. Ribeiro et al. found that resistance training does not promote increases in fat-free mass when not associated with nutritional support11, which may justify the results found in our study.

In this context, interventions that can promote the maintenance of these variables in patients with COPD are important for functional independence6, QoL7, decrease in hospitalizations and mortality8. In addition, the similar behavior of maintenance of these variables at 3 months follow-up in resistance training using elastic components and conventional training with weight machines is very important, because elastic components have advantages such as low cost, high portability and little demand for space3 compared with the conventional training. Considering this, it is much easier for patients to use such equipment at home if going to rehabilitation center is not possible. In conclusion, in the present study, at 3 months follow-up of resistance training with elastic components, there was maintenance of body composition, health status and PA levels in patients with COPD. However, there was a decrease in functional capacity, but only with minimum clinically important differences, in the ETG group.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank all the volunteers, the São Paulo State University (UNESP) for allowing the development of this research and for the funders of this research: São Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP) (#2017/10925-2 #2017/10145-7), National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq) (#470742/2014-3) and Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES)001.

Referências
[1]
C.F. Vogelmeier, G.J. Criner, F.J. Martinez, A. Anzueto, P.J. Barnes, J. Bourbeau, et al.
Global Strategy for the Diagnosis Management, and Prevention of Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease 2017 Report. GOLD Executive Summary.
American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine., 195 (2017), pp. 557-582
[2]
S.M. Scharf, N. Maimon, T. Simon-Tuval, B.J. Bernhard-Scharf, H. Reuveni, A. Tarasiuk.
Sleep quality predicts quality of life in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
International journal of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease., 6 (2010), pp. 1-12
[3]
E.M. Ramos, A.C. de Toledo-Arruda, L.C. Fosco, R. Bonfim, G.N. Bertolini, F.A. Guarnier, et al.
The effects of elastic tubing-based resistance training compared with conventional resistance training in patients with moderate chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a randomized clinical trial.
Clinical rehabilitation., 28 (2014), pp. 1096-1106
[4]
A. Nyberg, B. Lindstrom, A. Rickenlund, K. Wadell.
Low-load/high-repetition elastic band resistance training in patients with COPD: a randomized, controlled, multicenter trial.
The clinical respiratory journal., 9 (2015), pp. 278-288
[5]
D.D. Dunlop, L.M. Manheim, M.W. Sohn, X. Liu, R.W. Chang.
Incidence of functional limitation in older adults: the impact of gender, race, and chronic conditions.
Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation., 83 (2002), pp. 964-971
[6]
I.E. Mattos, C.N. do Carmo, L.M. Santiago, L.L. Luz.
Factors associated with functional incapacity in elders living in long stay institutions in Brazil: a cross-sectional study.
BMC geriatrics., 14 (2014), pp. 47
[7]
T. Troosters, R. Gosselink, M. Decramer.
Short- and long-term effects of outpatient rehabilitation in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a randomized trial.
The American journal of medicine., 109 (2000), pp. 207-212
[8]
S.F. Smagula, K.L. Stone, A. Fabio, J.A. Cauley.
Risk factors for sleep disturbances in older adults: Evidence from prospective studies.
Sleep medicine reviews., 25 (2016), pp. 21-30
[9]
S. Inoue, T. Yorifuji, M. Sugiyama, T. Ohta, K. Ishikawa-Takata, H. Doi.
Does habitual physical activity prevent insomnia? A cross-sectional and longitudinal study of elderly Japanese,.
Journal of aging and physical activity., 21 (2013), pp. 119-139
[10]
A.M. Schols, J. Slangen, L. Volovics, E.F. Wouters.
Weight loss is a reversible factor in the prognosis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine., 157 (1998), pp. 1791-1797
[11]
A.S. Ribeiro, A. Avelar, B.J. Schoenfeld, R.M. Ritti Dias, L.R. Altimari, E.S. Cyrino.
Resistance training promotes increase in intracellular hydration in men and women.
European journal of sport science., 14 (2014), pp. 578-585

Please cite this article as: Silva IG, Silva BSdA, Freire APCF, Santos APSd, Lima FFd, Ramos D, et al. Functionality of patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease at 3 months follow-up after elastic resistance training: a randomized clinical trial . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pulmoe.2018.09.005

Copyright © 2018. Sociedade Portuguesa de Pneumologia
Pulmonology

Subscribe to our newsletter

Article options
Tools
Supplemental materials

Are you a health professional able to prescribe or dispense drugs?

Cookies policy
To improve our services and products, we use cookies (own or third parties authorized) to show advertising related to client preferences through the analyses of navigation customer behavior. Continuing navigation will be considered as acceptance of this use. You can change the settings or obtain more information by clicking here.